Using Cracked CAD/CAM Software in Korea: Can You Be Punished? – How Vendors Detect It and How to Challenge Excessive Damages Claims Under Korean Copyright Law

·

·

Cracked CAD/CAM software in Korea – criminal liability, vendor detection, challenging excessive damages claims

Hello, I am Heejun Lee, a Korean attorney at Yeoam Law Firm in Seoul.

I have written before about how foreign rights holders can enforce their IP in Korea. This time I look at the other side: individuals and companies in Korea using commercial software such as CAD/CAM without a genuine licence. The scenario below is a fictional composite of several consultations.

“We are a small mould design company. Some time ago an employee installed a cracked 3D CAD package downloaded from the internet on three PCs, and we have been using it since. Now the vendor’s Korean law firm has sent a demand letter asking for several hundred million won, the full-package list price times three. We only used the basic functions. Do we have to pay all of that?”

Let me be clear first: using commercial software without a genuine licence can be a criminal offence, and the best course is not to use it. But if you have already been caught, you should know that the figure the rights holder demands is not necessarily what a court will award. Looking at other Korean lawyers’ case analyses and actual judgments, there are clear areas of copyright law interpretation that can be argued over, both on damages and on which provisions apply.

Key takeaways

  • Unauthorised copying and installation infringes the Copyright Act. Since the amendment effective 11 August 2026, the maximum penalty for infringing economic rights is 7 years’ imprisonment or a fine of KRW 100 million.
  • Vendors detect unlicensed use through usage data sent when the software runs, license compliance teams, outside investigation and legal partners, and tip-off channels.
  • Use for company business is easily treated as for profit, so withdrawing the complaint may not end the case, and the company itself can be punished under the joint penalty provision.
  • Damages are not simply “list price × number of PCs” but an objectively reasonable licence fee, which can be much lower depending on the modules used, period, licence model and discounts.
  • After detection, stop using the software and preserve records rather than deleting or reformatting.

1. You can be punished: the provisions that apply

ConductProvisionMaximum penalty
Copying and installing the program yourselfCopyright Act, Art. 136(1)7 years or KRW 100 million (acts from 11 August 2026; before that 5 years or KRW 50 million)
Knowingly using a pirated copy installed by someone else for businessArts. 124(1)(3) and 136(3)(4)3 years or KRW 30 million; cannot be punished against the victim’s express wishes
Bypassing licence activation (cracks, keygens)Arts. 104-2 and 136(3)(3-3)3 years or KRW 30 million if done as a business or for profit; no complaint required
Company liability for employees’ violationsArt. 141 (joint penalty)Fine for the company; exempt if it exercised reasonable care and supervision

Copyright offences in Korea generally require a complaint from the rights holder, but infringement for profit or on a habitual basis can be prosecuted without one (Art. 140). Courts tend to treat copying for company business as being for profit, and there are cases where a fine was imposed even after the complaint was withdrawn following a settlement. For foreigners, a criminal record can also count against you when extending your stay or changing your visa status.

2. How vendors find out

  • Usage data: many CAD/CAM programs send the date, time, IP address and device identifiers to the vendor’s servers when they run. This often works the same way for genuine and cracked copies, and vendors analyse the data to identify unlicensed users.
  • Internal compliance teams: major software companies have dedicated licence compliance functions that monitor use by region.
  • Outside partners: they work with Korean law firms, investigators and resellers to send demand letters, request audits and file criminal complaints. Many cases also start from industry reporting channels or tip-offs from former employees.
  • Law enforcement: once a complaint is filed, the police or the copyright special judicial police may search premises and examine PCs.

Assuming you are safe because you are a small company or because the PCs are offline often does not hold up in practice. The surest solution is to buy genuine licences or switch to alternative software.

3. If you are caught: areas of copyright law that can be argued

If the rights holder’s demand is excessive, these issues are worth examining. They are the points on which damages have varied greatly in actual judgments.

  • What “the amount normally receivable” means: damages under Article 125(2) are the objectively reasonable fee the infringer would have paid had it obtained a licence (Supreme Court rulings of 2001 and 2013). The list price quoted by the rights holder is not automatically that amount, and discounts and quotes in real transactions are also considered.
  • Modules actually used, not the full package: cracked versions are usually top-tier packages with every module. Courts have limited damages to the basic module or certain modules, looking at the actual work, company size and functions used. Reported judgments include one awarding KRW 9 million against a KRW 100 million claim, and another basing damages on a real quote obtained just after a search.
  • Period of use and licence model: whether the licence is perpetual or an annual subscription, and whether maintenance is included, changes the calculation.
  • Accuracy of device counts and IP addresses: lists of IP addresses or devices sometimes include ones unrelated to the company. Checking them alone can narrow your liability.
  • A reasonable amount under Article 126: where damages are hard to calculate, the court sets a reasonable amount based on all the circumstances. In many cases this has led to awards well below the claim.
  • Conditions for statutory and enhanced damages: statutory damages of up to KRW 10 million per work (KRW 50 million for intentional infringement for profit) require the work to have been registered before the infringement (Art. 125-2). Enhanced damages for intentional infringement introduced in 2026 apply only to infringements after the amendment took effect.
  • Which provision applies and whether a complaint is needed: the person who copied the program and the person who used a copy installed by someone else fall under different provisions (Supreme Court ruling of 2019), which changes the penalty and the effect of a settlement. Where use was for personal study unrelated to company business, there are cases where the profit motive was denied and the case ended when the complaint was withdrawn.
  • Company exemption from joint liability: records of genuine licence purchases, installation approval, security pledges and regular audits support an argument that the company exercised reasonable care and supervision.

4. What to do, and not do, right after detection

  • Stop using the software immediately, but do not delete it or reformat the PCs. That can look like destroying evidence and erases records you need to prove the actual scope of use.
  • Record and preserve when it was installed, by whom, on which devices, which functions were used and what was produced.
  • Do not reply to the demand letter with an admission of the amount. Review the scope and figure first, then negotiate.
  • In any settlement, spell out civil damages, withdrawal of the complaint or a no-punishment statement, waiver of further claims, and the programs and period covered.
  • Presenting a plan to buy the licences you need or move to alternative software helps in negotiations.

5. For foreigners and foreign-invested companies

The same law applies to foreign-invested companies and foreign engineers in Korea. Documents from the vendor’s Korean representatives are mostly in Korean, and criminal proceedings and civil negotiations often run in parallel. I explain demand letters and investigation documents directly in English, French, German or Korean, and can prepare both reports for your head office and written opinions in Korean.

Frequently asked questions

Q. Can a cracked version be detected if it is never connected to the internet?
You cannot assume it won’t be. Many commercial programs send usage data to the vendor’s servers when they run, and a single connection, update or plug-in installation can leave a record. There are also non-technical routes such as tip-offs from former employees and investigations by the vendor’s partners.

Q. Do I have to pay the amount stated in the demand letter?
No. That figure is the rights holder’s demand, not a confirmed amount of damages. Courts look at an objectively reasonable licence fee based on the modules actually used, the period, the licence model and usual discounts, not list price times the number of PCs, and some judgments have awarded far less than was claimed.

Q. If we settle, does the criminal case end too?
It depends on the provision that applies. Where a complaint is required, withdrawing it can end the case, but where the use is found to be for profit or habitual, or circumvention of technical protection is involved, a conviction is still possible after settlement. The settlement agreement must spell out exactly what civil and criminal matters it covers.

Q. An employee installed it without telling us. Can the company be punished?
Under the joint penalty provision, the company can also be fined. It can be exempt if it did not neglect reasonable care and supervision to prevent the violation, so records of genuine licence purchases, installation approval procedures and regular audits are important.

Final thoughts

Unlicensed use of CAD/CAM software is likely to be detected and can bring both criminal penalties and civil damages, so the best course is not to use it. But being caught does not mean you must accept whatever amount the rights holder demands. There is clear room to resolve the matter within a reasonable range, based on the actual scope of use and the damages rules of Korean copyright law.

If you have received a demand letter or criminal complaint, please gather the documents, details of installation and use, and your existing licences, and contact me via the KakaoTalk open chat below or by phone (+82-10-4692-6821). Consultations are available in English, French, German and Korean. You can also use the contact form or see my legal services for foreigners in Seoul.

More videos on Korean legal cases are on my YouTube channel (in Korean).

Related reading


Attorney responsible for this advertisement: Heejun Lee, Partner, Yeoam Law Firm · Tel. +82-10-4692-6821
This post is general legal information as of November 2026. It does not encourage or justify the use of unlicensed software. The outcome in any specific case depends on the facts, including how and how far the software was used, the evidence and the licence terms. The scenario above is a fictional composite of several consultations.

Read in other languages: 한국어 · Français · Deutsch

#SoftwarePiracyKorea #CrackedCAD #CopyrightKorea #SoftwareAudit #DemandLetter #CopyrightDamages #LicenceCompliance #HeejunLee #KoreanLawyer



Call Us +82 10-4692-6821 KakaoTalk Open Chat consultation